secrecy.
- Thread starter DNA
- Start date
Bob Franks
Past District Deputy Grand Lecturer
Should there be NO secrets?
When I was in the military, I had a Secret Clearance.
In my marriage, there are things I do not wish to discuss outside of it.
I will not give you my bank account number, bank routing number, or PIN.
In my work in medicine, I am sworn not to break patient confidences.
The only secrets in Masonry are the modes of recognition and the way we do our rituals.
As they are easily found by anyone intelligent enough to do a little research, they are kept secret by us in order that we may show we can keep our word.
The 'thing' is not the secrets, but that we do not violate our promise by revealing them to the uninitiated.
When I was in the military, I had a Secret Clearance.
In my marriage, there are things I do not wish to discuss outside of it.
I will not give you my bank account number, bank routing number, or PIN.
In my work in medicine, I am sworn not to break patient confidences.
The only secrets in Masonry are the modes of recognition and the way we do our rituals.
As they are easily found by anyone intelligent enough to do a little research, they are kept secret by us in order that we may show we can keep our word.
The 'thing' is not the secrets, but that we do not violate our promise by revealing them to the uninitiated.
CoachN
Builder Builder
If this is indeed true and you are a man of your word, then you would have no problem providing all the world with your SS#, mother's maiden name, account numbers and passwords to all your bank accounts.
When one thinks out what you claim, what you claim is not true.
Masonic training provides insights that you are not likely to obtain through usual channels of learning. But don't tell anyone this. It's not a secret, it's merely a little known fact -- even within Masonic circles.BTW - Their are no answers to life. Someone offered you bogus reading material.
Duncan1574
Lodge Chaplain & arms dealer
CoachN
Builder Builder
So, are you saying that the membership fees are no longer an issue for you? What changed for you between Oct 2009 and now?
LOL!!! Monery is no object! I smell me a troll... Must be in his "DNA"
removed12612
Guest
<---------- This guy right here thinks DNA is actually full of crap
Bob Franks
Past District Deputy Grand Lecturer
Let's give him some more rope, Gary; he can either make a lifeline...or a noose!LOL!!! Monery is no object! I smell me a troll... Must be in his "DNA"
S&F
CoachN
Builder Builder
Yup. In fact, if you are Christian, JC had a whole bunch of teachings supporting secrecy. The OT is also full of secrecy support. I'll bet that other faiths make comment upon this too.
Secrecy within Masonry imo, is sometimes misinterpreted. Imo, Freemasonry is more a Private organization than a Secret one. Our existence is public, many of our events are public and involve the general public. The only Secrets we have are the ways we recognize each other and how we bring in new members. Our Initiation ceremonies are Secret, however I cannot remember a single newly initiated member who felt "put off" by the obligatory secrecy after experiencing the ceremonies. Our level of secrecy is no higher than a business' secret operations. If you are really that concerned about it DNA, then I wouldn't recommend you petition. There are other organizations out there.
Meh, You may be right... But judging from his previous posts I'm a sceptic.
removed12612
Guest
<---------- This guy right here thinks DNA wont stage much of a rebuttal .....
BukeyeJackson
ViMH Advisory Board
############# is ######### # ### #### # Venice Beach####. Agent Super Secret Secret Squirrel!